Custom birthday cakes in Nacogdoches
From a first birthday to a fiftieth, Poppy Cakes bakes custom buttercream birthday cakes to order and delivers them fresh to your party.
- From $65
- Serves 5 to 60
- Free delivery in Nacogdoches
A birthday cake made just for them
The best birthday cakes say something about the person you're celebrating: their favorite color, the theme of the party, a hobby, or simply their name piped across the top. Lauren designs every birthday cake with you, so it looks the way you pictured and tastes as good as it looks.
Every cake is a single-tier, two- or three-layer buttercream cake, baked fresh for your date here in Nacogdoches with locally sourced ingredients. Send an inspiration photo, a party invitation, or a few words about the birthday girl or boy, and Lauren will create her own take on it.
First birthdays
A small, sweet cake for the guest of honor's first taste of buttercream.
Kids' parties
Bright colors, fun themes, and flavors kids actually finish.
Milestone birthdays
Elegant cakes for the 21st, 30th, 40th, 50th, and beyond.
SFA and college birthdays
Surprise a roommate or friend with a cake delivered anywhere in Nacogdoches.
Office birthdays
An 8 or 10 inch cake feeds the whole team.
Surprise parties
We'll work with whoever's planning so the secret stays safe.
How big a birthday cake?
Pick a size to see how many guests it serves and where pricing starts.
- Your cake
- Serves
- Starts at
A 6 inch cake is plenty for a small family party; most kids' parties of 15 to 25 guests are a good fit for an 8 or 10 inch cake. Your final quote is set once Lauren sees your design.
Ordering your birthday cake
- Book at least 10 days aheadWe take a limited number of orders each week, so popular weekends fill up first.
- Share your ideasYour date, guest count, flavors, colors, and any inspiration photos or party theme.
- Pick your flavorsVanilla, chocolate, or lemon cake with matching buttercream and fillings, plus seasonal flavors.
- We deliver to the partyFree anywhere in Nacogdoches, and within about 30 minutes of town for a fee in your quote.
Birthday cakes our customers love
Five-star Google reviews from Nacogdoches families.
The custom cake we got for our 1 year olds birthday party was unbelievable! It was exactly what we were looking for. And there was NONE left because of how delicious it was!! Thank you Poppy Cakes Banking Co.!!
Poppy Cakes did an awesome job with our kids birthday cakes. So yummy and kids taste test approved! She did everything perfect that we wanted for our custom cakes. Everyone should use Poppy Cakes in Nacogdoches!
Poppy Cakes was amazing!! The birthday cake tasted amazing and was exactly what we asked for! They were so easy to work with! Thank you Poppy Cakes!!
Birthday cake questions
How far ahead should I order a birthday cake?
Please order at least 10 days before the party. We take a limited number of orders each week, so booking earlier gives you the best chance at your date.
How much does a custom birthday cake cost?
Birthday cakes start at $65 for a 6 inch, two-layer cake that serves 5 to 9. Larger sizes start at $85 to $160. Your final price depends on your design and decorations.
Can you put a name or message on the cake?
Yes. Add the name, age, or message you'd like to your quote request, along with any colors or theme for the party.
Can you match my party theme or an inspiration photo?
Yes. Share your photo or theme with your quote request and Lauren will create her own take on it to fit your party.
Do you deliver birthday cakes in Nacogdoches?
Yes, every cake is delivered. Delivery is free anywhere in Nacogdoches, and we deliver within about a 30-minute drive of town for a fee that's included in your quote.
What size birthday cake do I need?
A 6 inch cake serves 5 to 12, an 8 inch serves 12 to 24, a 10 inch serves 20 to 40, and a 12 inch serves 35 to 60, depending on whether you choose two or three layers.
Let's plan the birthday cake
Order at least 10 days ahead. Lauren replies within two business days.