Anniversary cakes in Nacogdoches
Mark another year together with a custom buttercream anniversary cake, baked to order and delivered fresh to your home or celebration.
- From $65
- Dinner for two or a full party
- Free delivery in Nacogdoches
A sweet way to mark the years
Whether it's your first anniversary or your fiftieth, an anniversary cake turns an ordinary evening into a celebration. Lauren designs each one with you, from simple, romantic buttercream florals to a fresh take on the cake you cut on your wedding day.
Every anniversary cake is a custom, single-tier buttercream cake baked to order in Nacogdoches with locally sourced ingredients. Choose a small cake for a quiet dinner at home, or a larger one for a party with family and friends.
First anniversary
Skip the year-old frozen top tier and celebrate with a fresh one.
Silver and golden
Silver, gold, and ivory details for 25th and 50th anniversaries.
Vow renewals
An elegant single-tier cake for an intimate ceremony.
Anniversary parties
Larger cakes serving up to 60 guests.
Your wedding cake, made fresh
Many couples save the top tier of their wedding cake to eat on their first anniversary. A year in the freezer is hard on any cake.
Instead, send Lauren a photo of your wedding cake and your favorite flavors. She'll create her own single-tier take on it, baked fresh for your anniversary, so you can relive the moment and actually enjoy every bite.
Start your quote- Share a wedding photoAdd it to your quote request, along with your date and guest count.
- Pick your flavorsVanilla, chocolate, or lemon, with matching buttercream and fillings, plus seasonal flavors.
- Add a messageYour names, your wedding date, or the number of years.
How big an anniversary cake?
Pick a size to see how many it serves and where pricing starts.
- Your cake
- Serves
- Starts at
Our 6 inch cake is our smallest and works well for two, with leftovers to share. Your final quote is set once Lauren sees your design.
Loved by our customers
Five-star Google reviews for Poppy Cakes.
Poppy cakes makes the tastiest and most beautiful custom cakes! The colors are beautiful and the attention to detail sets them apart! Highly recommend for birthday party cakes or any special event!
Poppy Cakes is legit! The service is second to none. The owner is very sweet and cares about making the cake special for the occasion. Easily the best place in Nac for a birthday cake or graduation cake.
Poppy Cakes was amazing!! The birthday cake tasted amazing and was exactly what we asked for! They were so easy to work with! Thank you Poppy Cakes!!
Anniversary cake questions
Can you recreate our wedding cake for our anniversary?
Yes. Send a photo of your wedding cake with your quote request and Lauren will create her own single-tier take on it, baked fresh for your anniversary.
Do you make small anniversary cakes for two?
Our smallest cake is a 6 inch, two-layer cake that serves 5 to 9 and starts at $65. It's a great size for a dinner at home, with some left over.
How much does an anniversary cake cost?
Anniversary cakes start at $65. Larger sizes for parties start at $85 to $160. Your final price depends on your design and decorations.
How far ahead should I order?
Please order at least 10 days before your anniversary. We take a limited number of orders each week, so earlier is better.
Can you deliver the cake as a surprise?
Yes, every cake is delivered. Let us know the address and the best time in your quote request. Delivery is free anywhere in Nacogdoches and available within about a 30-minute drive of town for a fee included in your quote.
Let's celebrate your years together
Order at least 10 days ahead. Lauren replies within two business days.